How to Compare Roofing Quotes in Seattle (What Gets Missed)

How to Compare Roofing Quotes in Seattle (What Gets Missed)

Quick answer: Compare roofing quotes line by line, not by the total at the bottom. Two quotes only compare fairly when they cover the same work, the same materials, and the same warranty, and the lowest one is often missing something.

What should a roofing quote include?

A complete roof replacement quote names every step of the job. Here is what is in every quote we write, and what you should look for in any quote:

  • Tear-off of the old roof
  • Haul away and disposal
  • Synthetic underlayment
  • Ice and water shield
  • Drip edge
  • The shingles, named by brand and product line
  • Ridge cap
  • Re-flashing of every penetration, such as pipes and vents
  • Cleanup and a magnet sweep for nails

If a line is not written down, do not assume it is included. Ask.

What is often left out of a roofing quote?

The items most often missing are the ones you cannot see from the street. Check each quote for these:

ItemWhat to ask
Tear-off and disposalIs the old roof coming off down to the wood, and is the dump fee included?
Rotted deckingWhat is the price per sheet if bad wood is found? We usually charge $80 to $100 per sheet.
FlashingIs the flashing being replaced, or is the old flashing being reused?
Ice and water shieldWhere is it going on the roof?
Attic ventilationWas it checked, and is any vent work in the price?
PermitsDoes this city require one, and who pays for it?
Sales taxIs the total shown with tax or before tax?
WarrantyWhat is covered, for how long, and who backs it?
CleanupIs a magnet sweep for nails included?

On permits, the rules change by city. Inside the City of Seattle, a permit is not required for re-roof work on one- and two-family homes and townhouses when the only change to the building envelope is adding or replacing insulation. Other cities have their own rules, so the quote should name the city.

Why are roofing quotes so far apart for the same house?

Usually for two reasons. The roof was measured differently, and the quotes do not cover the same work.

One roofer may guess the size from the ground. Another may measure it. One may include new flashing and a decking price. Another may leave both out and bring them up after the old roof is off.

A measured baseline helps. Our free roof cost calculator measures your roof by satellite and shows what it should cost. It also has a quote checker where you enter the price another roofer gave you. For local price ranges, see how much a new roof costs in Seattle.

How do I make sure the quotes are for the same shingle?

Look for the exact product name on each quote. "Architectural shingles" is not enough. Shingle lines differ in price and in looks, so a quote for one line cannot be compared to a quote for another.

We install GAF shingles in three levels: Timberline HDZ (good), Timberline UHDZ (better), and Grand Sequoia (best). Our quotes name the line and the color. You can see the GAF colors here.

How do I check that a roofer is licensed and insured in Washington?

Look them up at lni.wa.gov/verify, the Washington State Department of Labor and Industries lookup. It is free and takes a minute. You can see:

  • Whether the contractor's registration is active
  • Whether there are lawsuits against their bond
  • Whether they have an active workers' comp account
  • Whether they have safety citations or other infractions

Do this for every roofer you are considering, including us.

How many roofing quotes should I get?

Get more than one, and get them in writing. The Department of Labor and Industries tells homeowners to interview several qualified, registered contractors and to get the bids in writing.

The department also says to compare more than price. Look at the start and end dates, the products to be used, and the warranties offered, and confirm that permit fees, taxes, and other costs are in the bid.

What warranty should a roofing quote come with?

Two kinds, both in writing. A manufacturer warranty covers the roofing products. A workmanship warranty covers the installation.

Ask each roofer who backs the workmanship warranty and for how long. We give a 10-year workmanship warranty, and as a GAF Certified Plus contractor we can register the GAF Silver Pledge warranty. Our roof warranty guide explains what it covers.

What payment terms are normal for a roof replacement?

A down payment to start and the rest when the job is done. The Department of Labor and Industries advises a reasonable down payment and says not to pay in full until all the work is finished and you are satisfied.

Our terms are 50% down and the balance on completion. Be careful with any quote that asks for the full amount before work starts.

Is the cheapest roofing quote the best one?

Not always. A low number often means something on the list above was left out, and that cost tends to come back later as an add-on or a leak. A high number is not proof of quality either.

Put the quotes side by side, line up what each one includes, and then compare the totals. If you want a second set of eyes on a quote you already have, send it to us. Request your free estimate here or call (206) 656-4999.

BSR Constructions LLC is a family-owned, licensed and insured Seattle roofing contractor rated 4.9 stars on Google, and a GAF Certified Plus contractor. Estimates are free and every quote is in writing. Call (206) 656-4999.

roofing quotesroof replacementhiring a rooferroof costseattle roofing

Need a roofer in Seattle?

Free inspection and a clear written estimate. Call (206) 656-4999 or request yours online.

Get My Free Estimate
← Back to Blog